Professional Book Publishing Services – Urban Quill Publishing

Menu
Call Now

10 Common Cover Design Mistakes That Kill Book Sales (And How to Avoid Them)

There’s something strange that happens when you publish a book: people judge it before they ever read a word.

It might feel unfair. You spent months, maybe years, pouring your heart onto the page…
and readers make their decision in the space of a breath. One glance at the cover.

It’s not personal. It’s human.

A cover is the first handshake, the front porch light, the quiet invitation that says, “Come in. There’s a story waiting for you.”

So if your book isn’t selling the way you hoped, the cover might be whispering the wrong message.

Here are ten common mistakes indie authors make.

1. Too Many Fonts

When a cover uses three, four, or five fonts, it starts to feel chaotic, like a kitchen drawer full of mismatched spatulas.

Avoid:

  • More than two fonts
  • Decorative fonts for the main title
  • Odd combinations that fight each other

Try instead:
One clean font for the title, one simple font for your name. Let the story, not the typography, be the noise-maker.

2. Colors That Clash or Distract

Some covers look like a sunset fighting with a highlighter. Readers don’t always know why it feels “off,” but they scroll past anyway.

Avoid:

  • Neon colors
  • Random combinations
  • Heavy saturation everywhere

Try instead:
Calm, intentional colors that match your genre: warm tones for romance, deep shadows for thrillers, soft palettes for literary fiction.

3. Trying to Show Everything

Many authors try to cram their whole story onto the cover; every character, symbol, scene, and theme. It becomes a crowded living room with no space to breathe.

Avoid:

  • Busy collages
  • Overstuffed imagery

Try instead:
One strong image. The most important one. Let mystery do the rest.

4. Hard-to-Read Titles

If someone has to squint, the sale is already gone.

Avoid:

  • Small titles
  • Thin fonts
  • Low contrast

Try instead:
Bold, clear lettering that reads even in tiny thumbnail size (since most readers find books online first).

5. Genre Mismatch

The fastest way to confuse a reader is to give your book the wrong “uniform.”

A romantic comedy that looks like a crime thriller? A mystery that looks like a cookbook? Readers walk by thinking, “Not for me.”

Try instead:
Study the top 50 books in your category. Let the patterns guide you; not copy, just understand the language your genre speaks.

6. Poor Image Quality

Blurry photos or stretched graphics make a book look unpolished, even if the writing inside is beautiful.

Avoid:

  • Low-resolution images
  • Pixelated artwork
  • Stretched stock photos

Try instead:
High-quality, high-resolution visuals, clear enough to feel intentional.

7. Forgetting About the Thumbnail View

Most readers see your book first on a tiny screen: a phone held in one tired hand while the other stirs dinner or rocks a baby. If the title disappears at small size, the book disappears with it.

Try:
Zoom out. Make sure everything still works when the cover is small.

8. Overusing Stock Photos

One stock image may appear on a hundred books. Readers notice. It breaks the spell.

Avoid:
Obvious, cliché stock photos that look like advertisements.

Try instead:
Photos or illustrations chosen with real care, distinct enough to feel like they belong only to your story.

9. No Visual Hierarchy

Some covers feel “messy” without anything technically being wrong. Usually this is because nothing is guiding the eye.

Try:
Make the title the loudest element.
Your name a gentle whisper.
Everything else supporting the mood.

10. DIY Without Guidance

There’s no shame in making your own cover. Many authors start that way, just like cooking your first meal with whatever you have in the pantry.

But sometimes the cover needs a cleaner eye. A steadier hand. Someone who knows how readers think when they browse.

This is where a professional design team (like the one at Urban Quill Publishing) can make a quiet but powerful difference. They take your vision and shape it into something that feels like a real book, the kind readers trust at first glance.

Your story is ready. Let’s help it find its readers.

Get Started Now

How to Avoid These Mistakes (Without Feeling Overwhelmed)

You don’t need to be a designer to choose a good design.
You just need to:

  1. Keep things simple
  2. Follow your genre
  3. Use clear, readable text
  4. Choose one strong image
  5. Let the cover feel like an open door, not a puzzle

Start with calm decisions.
Start with breathing room.
Your book will thank you.

When You Want Help Bringing Your Vision to Life

If you’ve done all you can and the cover still feels “off,” it might be time for another set of eyes, someone trained to see the tiny things that matter.

A full-service publisher like Urban Quill Publishing has designers who understand:

  • color psychology
  • typography
  • genre expectations
  • layout balance
  • branding for long-term author growth

They help you build not just a cover, but a connection… that quiet spark that makes someone stop, look closer, and think, “I want to read this.”

Recent Post

Scroll to Top